Small town teacher Nicole Pepper is thrilled to be traveling to the city to celebrate the wedding of her college roommate, Jessica, and stand as her maid of honor. It will be a lavish affair, not least because Jessica's family owns the city's baseball team. Still jaded from a previous relationship, the last thing Nicole is looking for is love. However, when sparks fly between her and the best man, the devastatingly charming All-Star catcher, Gage Anderson, she is taken aback. But Gage isn't the only man who's set his sights on her. Caught between two men and still haunted by her past, who will catch Nicole's heart?